Which Semi-Precious Stones Do U.S. Buyers Want Most in 2026?

Amethyst, turquoise or moonstone — which should your next wholesale order lead with? If you sell to the U.S. market, this is not a matter of taste: it is a matter of data. The Plumb Club's 2025 U.S. consumer survey gives us the clearest same-question comparison available for these stones, and it points to one buying plan. Here is what the numbers say and how to build a stone mix around them.

Left to right: amethyst, turquoise, moonstone.

What the U.S. Data Says

In the same Plumb Club consumer survey (U.S. consumers, multiple choice, fielded February 2025), three stones stand out among the natural semi-precious stones we set:

1. Amethyst — The Consistent Leader

Amethyst holds 27% preference in back-to-back survey waves, and it carries three extra demand drivers:

• Birthstone reach — amethyst is the February birthstone, and 65% of U.S. consumers actively look for jewelry featuring their birthstone.
• Color depth — from pale lavender to deep violet, it photographs well and flatters most skin tones, which keeps it safe for Etsy and TikTok content.
• Proven price ladder — verified listings span a dainty 925 silver pendant around $55 up to a faceted 925 necklace at $176, so you can build both entry and gifting SKUs from one stone.

2. Turquoise — The Fastest Riser

Turquoise gained the most ground of any stone in our scope (23% → 25%), and it behaves differently from amethyst — more statement, more color, more fashion-forward.

• Instant identity — the blue-green color makes pieces read "boho" or "western" at a glance; a dainty turquoise ring carries a bestseller badge and strong review counts on Etsy.
• Rising popularity in verified listings — from a dainty adjustable ring around $34 to a halo ring at $160, the mid-range is active.
• One compliance caveat — distinguish natural, stabilized and reconstituted turquoise in your listings. "Natural" claims need supplier documentation.

3. Moonstone — The Steady Second Line

Moonstone sits at 17% — lower, but it has something the other two lack: a built-in spiritual story that pairs well with amethyst.

• Spiritual narrative — moon/moonstone ties into the moon-phase and intuition content that drives TikTok and Etsy searches.
• Color contrast — white/rainbow moonstone next to amethyst gives you a light-dark mix in one collection, which lifts perceived variety.
• Healthy margin anchor — verified 925 moonstone pieces list in the $86 range, comfortably inside the $50–200 sweet spot.

Style Trends That Move Stone Demand

Stone choice does not happen in a vacuum — three style signals are compounding demand for these stones right now:

• Birthstone & sentimental — 65% of U.S. consumers actively seek birthstone designs (Rapaport, Plumb Club survey).
• Zodiac & spiritual — Etsy reports zodiac jewelry searches up 400% year over year.
• Vivid color — preference for vividly colored gemstones rose to 39% in the same Plumb Club survey (from 32% in 2023), which directly favors amethyst and turquoise over pale stones.

What This Means for Your Buying Plan

For a B2B buyer testing the U.S. market, the data supports a two-tier stone strategy:

One more practical note: 925 silver is priced per gram and metal prices move, so for larger silver orders we usually agree a lock-price or batch-splitting term on raw silver before production. It keeps your landed cost predictable while you scale whichever stone wins.

Send Your Inquiry